Friday, November 2, 2012

Tamron Quick Comparison (17-50mm and 18-200mm)


I bought  the Tamron 18-200mm as surf season is supposed to be coming and I needed one. Hopefully the waves will come soon. Since a few mos ago I've been using the Tamron 17-50mm and its a nice lens for taking portraits, quite sharp and built tough like a grenade. 

The 18-200mm is cheaper than the 17-50mm by a few hundred dollars  and it isn't that sharp but if in well lighted situations, i think it will be a good lens to have specially with the price and 200mm range. The AF goes crazy trying to focus in low light so its best to use Manual.

For Tamron and Sigma lenses, the most common problem is Err 01, which is faulty communication between the camera and lens. Once you have this, other people would say a firmware update or simply cleaning the contacts will fix it, but 99 percent of the time, it does not. So when you buy these brands, make sure it is still under warranty and thoroughly test the actual lens.

 Click here for a background on this problem.

Click here for  price and specs  comparison.
For 17-50mm REVIEW.
For 18-200 REVIEW.
Tamron 18-200mm f3.5-6.3 XR LD Aspherical (IF) Macro
Made in China

200mm f6.3 1/80 ISO100

  38mm f4 1/250 ISO100

 54mm f4.5 1/125 ISO100

 200mm f6.3 1/100 ISO100

200mm f6.3 1/250 ISO100


 200mm f6.3 1/80 ISO100


200mm f6.3 1/6 iso1600

 18mm f3.5 1/30 iso1600


87mm  f5.6 1/15 iso1600


54mm f4.5 1/6 iso1600

 200mm f6.3 1/800 ISO200

200mm f11 1/320 ISO200


47mm f4.5 1/15 ISO 400 A photo of the other lens using the 18-200mm


 Tamron 17-50mm f2.8 XR LD Aspherical (IF) 
Made in Japan
50mm f4.5 1/30 ISO400

50mm f2.8 1/1250 ISO200

 17mm f2.8 1/640 ISO200

50mm f2.8 1/800 ISO200

19mm f2.8 1/160 ISO800

 31mm f2.8 1/50 ISO1600

45mm f2.8 1/40 ISO200  A photo of the other lens using the 17-50mm.


All photos are unedited and was shot in JPEG.


No comments:

Post a Comment